Who loves and Hates Hannah Montana?

Who Loves or hates her?

  • Total voters
    16
Status
Not open for further replies.
Does Hannah Montana or Miley Cyrus appeal to all audiences? No, absolutely not. Will Miley Cyrus come out with new material every year? No. Will people still listen to her after 10 years? No. Will I be loyal to the bands that don't sell out to the mainstream in 10 years? Yes.
 
Woe be to those who are going to follow anything that isnt mainstream. That is perhaps the weirdest thing to do, what if your favorite groups became mainstream!?! Would you forgo them?! If any of my groups dropped out of the mainstream then I would forego them. I only listen to that which is most popular not what is pleasing.
 
Would I listen to my favorite bands if they went into the mainstream? Yes, only if they kept their quality up. And for that last statement that you made, that just makes you a sell out and really don't have a musical opinion and this whole thing is pointless since you have no emotion or faith in the music that you listen to, which is truly really sad.
 
I clearly established that I listen to Hannah Montana cause her music is definitely lyrically powerful and speaks of moral truths. By pleasing, I meant more on the lines of music that just speaks of things that I dont agree with for the sake of it only having as some people have called and termed as a good beat.
 
Yeah and thats what makes Hannah Montana and others that I listen to different, they continue to remain unique and interesting while not speaking of things that i dont agree with
 
Starrynite said:
I clearly established that I listen to Hannah Montana cause her music is definitely lyrically powerful and speaks of moral truths. By pleasing, I meant more on the lines of music that just speaks of things that I dont agree with for the sake of it only having as some people have called and termed as a good beat.
Click to expand...

you contradict yourself so much that is not even funny....

ok visualise this, imagine that hannah montana is not popular but her songs are the same would you still listen to her??? acording to what you said before you wouldn't because she is not mainstream, so make up your mind.
 
Starrynite said:
No it isnt, in life there are some things that must be true or not true, commanded or demanded, forced or not forced, and liking Hannah Montana is one of those things that must be a truth.
Click to expand...
The entire point to that post was that the entire thing is opinion-based, which you just confirmed in your post.
Starrynite said:
That doesnt make sense, if her voice was irritating then she wouldnt be selling to millions of people
Click to expand...
Like you said in your other post, Hannah Montana is not an absolute truth. You don't have to think she has an amazing voice because she sells a lot of records, as it is based on personal views.
Starrynite said:
Yes, thus because it is selling millions that means that we are commanded to like Hannah Montana.
Click to expand...
I just don't understand why you place so much importance on popularity sometimes. Just because all of the lemmings jump from the cliff doesn't mean everyone else must follow them.
Starrynite said:
Im sorry but your dead wrong. Listening to someone because they sell millions is one of the main reasons of listening to singers. If there are millions willing to listen then that must tell you that it is good music and that you must keep listening.
Click to expand...
By that logic, you could say that slavery was good because a lot of people had slaves. >_>
Starrynite said:
Woe be to those who are going to follow anything that isnt mainstream. That is perhaps the weirdest thing to do, what if your favorite groups became mainstream!?! Would you forgo them?! If any of my groups dropped out of the mainstream then I would forego them. I only listen to that which is most popular not what is pleasing.
Click to expand...
Woe to the lemmings who jump blindly off of the cliff, just to follow the crowd.

Honestly, I have to say that I almost pity you (I don't mean any offense), if the last part of your post is true. If that post is true, then you are nothing more than a reflection of what the majority thinks. I view the loss of individuality and free thought to be a great tragedy, so I must say I truly do feel bad for you because you have made your own opinion meaningless to yourself.
 
Fr0dus Maximus said:
Metal =/= screaming into mic. kthxbai
Click to expand...

Metalcore, grindcore, whatever, any of that garbage, I can't stand. I can appreciate talented metal musicians, though, like Metallica, Iron Maiden, Dream Theatre and Opeth.
 
Hinesmdc said:
Metalcore, grindcore, whatever, any of that garbage, I can't stand. I can appreciate talented metal musicians, though, like Metallica, Iron Maiden, Dream Theatre and Opeth.
Click to expand...

Screamo, Emo, Hardcore, Death Metal, Black Metal, Grindcore. not Metal in general.
 
Fr0dus Maximus said:
Screamo, Emo, Hardcore, Death Metal, Black Metal, Grindcore. not Metal in general.
Click to expand...

All disgusting. Take Job For A Cowboy, for example. I have never touched a guitar in my life, yet I could play all of their songs with no trouble. It's talentless music, with god awful vocals.
 
Hinesmdc said:
All disgusting. Take Job For A Cowboy, for example. I have never touched a guitar in my life, yet I could play all of their songs with no trouble. It's talentless music, with god awful vocals.
Click to expand...

I doubt you can play any song having never played a guitar. I respect any musician because I am a musician and I can guarantee a lot of people don't like what I play but I still deserve their respect for creating music that I enjoy and put my true self in. Who cares if a song is easy? Free Bird is easy but everyone idolizes it.
 
Starrynite said:
That doesnt make sense, if her voice was irritating then she wouldnt be selling to millions of people
Click to expand...
5 year old girls don't have the best taste in music.
 
Hannah Montana is the teenage, girly, stupid reincarnation of Satan. Not to mention I'd rather listen to a cat cough up a hairball than listen to any of her music.
 
NickThePunk said:
I doubt you can play any song having never played a guitar. I respect any musician because I am a musician and I can guarantee a lot of people don't like what I play but I still deserve their respect for creating music that I enjoy and put my true self in. Who cares if a song is easy? Free Bird is easy but everyone idolizes it.
Click to expand...

I wasn't making fun of it because it's easy, believe me, I am a sucker for simple, pretty songs. I was only saying that they just mindlessly attack their guitars in an attempt to sound "hardcore," and don't actually play good music.
 
Hinesmdc said:
I wasn't making fun of it because it's easy, believe me, I am a sucker for simple, pretty songs. I was only saying that they just mindlessly attack their guitars in an attempt to sound "hardcore," and don't actually play good music.
Click to expand...

Okay well then yeah if you don't like it that's fine but I'm just saying don't hate just because they are playing what they like. I don't know how to word it.
 
NickThePunk said:
Okay well then yeah if you don't like it that's fine but I'm just saying don't hate just because they are playing what they like. I don't know how to word it.
Click to expand...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AWggPLXeOkU

Proves my point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top